Skip to content

Google+: first impressions from the first week

July 12, 2011

Google+ overview

Welcome to Google+, your next social network?

A surprising number of people have asked me about Google+, the new social network from our new overlords. This isn’t the digital company’s first foray into social networks, after the underwhelming offerings of Orkut and Google Buzz. (Only in 2011 can a network like Orkut have 100 million users and be considered a relative failure.)

Before I offer my somewhat premature take on Google+, let me put forth a few disclaimers …

  1. It has been only a week. I bet The Facebook, as it was known early on, wasn’t that interesting in its first week.
  2. It’s underpopulated. Hard to kick the tires on a social network when a majority of my G+ connections work in … social media. (Oy, the endless conversations about G+ …)
  3. It’s not my raison d’être. I don’t want to be a pioneer in G+; all I want to do is quickly assess the best way to use it personally and professionally, and how it might (might) help your business grow.

OK, good? Let’s go!

Getting started

Google+ rolled out last week to a select few, but has grown through controlled periods allowing invitees to enter the beta social network. Many people are fond of Google’s other services (including me), such as Google Docs, Maps, Picasa (soon to be Google Pics) and more.

Google bar

You will find the now familiar elements of popular networks Facebook and Twitter. For starters, you have a stream of updates from your connections, including text, photos, links and videos. The interface still needs work: Imagine scanning your Facebook wall and having to scan past 100-plus comments on a popular post with no way to collapse the thread.

Sticking your friends in Circles

One of the most discussed features is how G+ organizes connections. Like Twitter, you can “follow” others and they can follow you, but no reciprocity is required (as mandated in Facebook). I could add up to 5,000 people to each of my Circles, and still only have 12 people follow me (or vice versa).

The Circles are how connections are organized. I can have as many Circles as I want: Friends, Close Friends, Relatives in Idaho, Co-Workers, Gun Club Buddies and so on. I can put my pal Johnny in both Friends and Gun Club Buddies, and my boss Sheila in Co-Workers. A Circle can even have zero connections, which you could use for Drafts or Bookmarks.

Google+ Circles

Adding people to Circles (even creating new ones) is as simple as
drag and drop in Google+. 

Johnny and Sheila can set up their own Circles, with or without me in any of them.

Many have praised this feature, but Facebook has had Friend Lists since at least 2007. (I was surprised when I realized how few Facebook users knew about lists or used them.)

The only difference? It’s mandatory to immediately classify each Google connection in a Circle, not so in Facebook. To me, it’s extra work and brain power to have to classify someone on the spot, then eventually have to reclassify later.

You can read the stream, or narrow it by Circle, just like in Facebook. Circles and Facebook Friend Lists, by the way, are invisible to anyone but you — handy if you have one called Loud-Mouthed Jerks.

The complicated world of sharing

Sharing is also similar to Facebook. One advantage is you can drag and drop photos, videos and links to the sharing box, though I haven’t been able to make it work consistently.

The most noticeable difference is that G+ asks each time how you want to share an item: in Public, with specific Circles or even one or two people. The Facebook interface isn’t nearly as good, but I typically share everything with everyone. (Enjoy my social media rants, former third-grade classmates! Interact with me on neighborhood issues, national social media experts!)

Google+ sharing box

Sharing in Google+ puts a premium on privacy and targeted information.

The confusion arises in if what you actually share makes it to your intended audience. For example, if I share something with just my Co-Workers Circle, I’m intending for my boss Sheila and the 25 others in my department to see it. But will they?

If Sheila has me in a Circle, let’s say Underlings, then yes, she will see it if she happens to be on G+ at the time, mixed in with other updates from those peons. But what if Sheila hasn’t added me to a single Circle (sniff!)? She could see my G+ posts if she clicks on the Incoming stream, designed to harness all those posts from unmade connections.

When I click on Incoming, I see a stream of not-very-interesting posts from complete strangers. In any stream, I can Mute a Post (hide it) or Block a Person (hide everything from and to someone). You can undo either Mute or Block at any time.

Better ways to combine and mute Circles will come in handy if they choose to add that functionality.

Pressing the +1 button repeatedly until you can cross the street

Even more confusing is the +1 button popping up on G+ and on sites everywhere, including this one. When you press it, this post receives a +1 (yay!). (Press it again and it undoes it. Boo.)

Google+ +1 buttonBut does pressing +1 mean you’re sharing it in your stream? No. You still have to put it in your sharing box (or use a Chrome or Firefox extension to automate the process). It does show up as a new link on your G+ profile’s +1 tab, but that seems pretty useless to me. (And no, it doesn’t go to Google Buzz either.)

By the way, all that +1 jazz applies only to websites, but not within G+ itself. I could mark 100 posts, photos and updates with +1, and it will be visible only to the original sharer and people within those Circles. That’s right: The +1 button behaves differently within Google+ than outside of it.


(This is why I hate trying to explain how a social network actually functions to people who have likely not been on it yet or for very long. It’s like trying to explain your vacation in the sixth dimension when you return home to the third dimension.)

Hangouts and Sparks

One feature I look forward to trying out is Hangouts, video chat and screen sharing with up to nine other people, whether within a specific Circle or a select few. I’ve been told it’s easy to set up and use. I’m also just vain enough to admit I don’t know if I’m ready for the bold new future of video calls all the time.

Video: Hangouts could be a great way for people to collaborate in real time,
whether jamming on music or ideas.

The other notable feature is Sparks, which allows you to pick keywords, topics, even URLs to follow. However, it doesn’t work very well yet.

Also not available yet is an official Search function, which is very useful for me to monitor trends in Twitter and Facebook. You can still search externally using Google, and I would tell you how, except that someone shared it in G+ and naturally, I can’t find it.

Time for your company to jump in?

The million dollar question to be answered is how businesses can leverage this new network for their nefarious ends. Google has promised separate profiles for businesses, while also promising to remove commercial profiles for the time being. This hasn’t stopped Ford Motor Company, one of the more adept brands in social media, from creating a profile that has yet to be excised.

Should your company be on Google+? When you’re ready to ask that question, contact me. For 99 percent of companies, the answer is no … for the time being. Most of them are probably underutilizing the more established social networks, not to mention their own email lists and traditional media mentions and buys.

Should you be on Google+? If you don’t mind being Google’s guinea pig, head to to see if you can get in. Or contact me for an invite and include your email address.

The future could be Google+, but the future looks a lot like right now.

What are your first impressions of Google+? Loving it, or finding it meh? Let us know in the comments.


More on social media and blogging every week.
Sign up for our free e-newsletter today!


15 Comments leave one →
  1. July 12, 2011 9:25 am

    Oh dear…I didn’t need this 🙂 Another place to be. I have seen several people asking if we wanted invites to this and I had no clue what they were talking about, so now I know 🙂 Is this intended to replace Facebook or be a side kick?

    • July 12, 2011 11:12 am

      Google intends it to be a Facebook killer, don’t doubt that for a second. But we get to decide.
      Just remember, millions said they’d never ever do Facebook, and now they’re happily Poking and Liking and playing Mafia Wars.
      Thanks for your comment.

  2. July 12, 2011 10:56 am

    Thanks for the review Wade! I’ve been looking for a “real” opinion about G+ to decide if i even WANT an invite… Sounds pretty cool so far. I’m liking Circles and I think Hangouts has potential in the future.

    • July 12, 2011 11:14 am

      You’re welcome, Josh. Were you using Friend Lists in Facebook? Do you see good potential for photographers in Google+? I know some were concerned about loss of ownership of photos if uploaded to Facebook.

  3. July 12, 2011 12:21 pm

    I can’t see your +1 button on this post. Which I would like to push, because I love this post!

  4. July 12, 2011 12:26 pm

    Ah, now I can see it!

    • July 12, 2011 1:22 pm

      I should’ve rigged every link on this post to give it +1.

      P.S. I tested this post with all of your moms for readability and ease of use.

  5. July 12, 2011 4:51 pm

    Great information, Wade. Thanks for the educated opinions as well. I think I’m going to let Google+ finds its own way before I jump in with both feet.

  6. July 13, 2011 4:56 pm

    great article… Google+ seems to have potential… I am in and have a profile. After that I haven’t done much. It took me forever to get on the Facebook band wagon, and now that I am there I really like it. Untill all my friends leave me alone on FB, I will probably just do most of my social media there and on Twitter. I really don’t need a 3rd thing to check!

    • July 15, 2011 12:21 pm

      Or in my case, a 12th thing to check. 🙂 Thanks for your insights, Melissa. I’ll keep you posted on the Google+ front.

  7. July 15, 2011 9:33 am

    Thanks for your great explanation of Google+. I’m still not sure if I want to do it or not. I do like the ideas of Circles, but it seems like I might miss some things from people if I’m not careful how I set it up and then how I check it.

    • July 15, 2011 12:27 pm

      I’m still not sure either, Kris. I’d like to try out Hangouts and I hope they’ll add screen sharing to it. Then, it might be worth more time for me. Thanks for your comment.


  1. 5 things your company could do in digital marketing right now « Birmingham Blogging Academy
  2. Weekly Wanderings - Adventures in Life, Love and Librarianship

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: